By using this website you agree to our Cookie policy

July 1998

Vol. 140 | No. 1144

The Burlington Magazine

Editorial

Stones of Florence

A one-day conference on urban 'degrado' held at the Accademia del Disegno in Florence on 15th May aired many of the issues that have preoccupied editorial comment on the city in this Magazine over the last half century, as well as producing some radical new suggestions for the future of Florence's monuments and works of sculpture. Organised by the Dipartimento di Storia dell'Architettura e Restauro of Florence University, the conference was launched as the first in an annual series addressing the problems of architectural and urban 'decay' (the bilingual title acknowledging the historic interventions of Anglo-Saxon commentators into debates on the state of the city).

 

Editorial read more
  • New Documents for Sassetta and Sano di Pietro at the Porta Romana, Siena

    By Machtelt Brüggen Israëls

    The history of the Coronation of the Virgin fresco on the Porta Romana in Siena (Fig. 1) is well known and well documented. In 1416 the city council asked Taddeo di Bartolo to paint a representation of the Madonna on the gate, but he seems not to have embarked on the commission by the time of his death in 1422. New life was breathed into the enterprise in 1442, and in 1447 Sassetta began the work. By the time he died in 1450, he had executed the angel choirs in the vault and had completed the design for the rest of the composition. His place was taken in 1459 by Sano di Pietro, who finished the Coronation of the Virgin almost a decade later. Over subsequent centuries the fresco was much damaged by exposure to the elements and finally by allied bombing in 1944; it has been restored several times.' Only the angels in the vault are fairly well preserved, while the Coronation itself has almost disappeared. In the 1970s the much-damaged fresco was detached and placed on the inner facade of the church of S. Francesco. On that occasion the technique was studied closely: traces of spolvero were found in the angel choirs in the vault, while sinopie were exposed under the Coronation (Figs.2 and 6). The purpose of this article is to publish some new documents (see the Appendix below), which expand our knowledge of the genesis of the fresco and its makers and provide fascinating information about the early use of cartoons.

     

  • Towards a New Chronology for Ridolfo Ghirlandaio and Michele Tosini

    By David Franklin

    In an article published in this Magazine in 1993, I attempted to provide fixed dates for some surviving altar-pieces produced by Ridolfo Ghirlandaio and his workshop in the second decade of the sixteenth century,' and suggested that the received view of Ridolfo's production prior to 1520 should be modified. The elevated patronage he received from the Medici and other prominent Florentine families and corporations - which still awaits thorough study - should alone justify serious interest in his work. Ridolfo is also one of the relatively few renaissance artists who came to move in the same circles as their patrons. In 1510 he married Contessina di Giovanbatista di Bianco Deti, from a family who could boast a Gonfaloniere of Justice as early as 1344,2 and he himself was apparently made 'de collegio' under the Medici principate,3 so becoming eligible for political office, although there is no evidence that he ever assumed such a role. He was, however, chosen by the confraternity of S. Maria della Croce al Tempio in Florence to be captain, with Manni Albizi, of the Quarter of San Giovanni in 1535 as a hitherto unknown document shows.4 Given Vasari's constant stress on the status of artists, it is surprising that he did not make more of Ridolfo's social standing. However, the tone of his biography of Ridolfo is perfectly neutral and uncritical, and one might be forgiven for supposing that he preferred Ridolfo to, for example, his greatly superior but more various and difficult contemporary, Pontormo.

     

  • The 'Master of the Kress Landscapes' Unmasked: Giovanni Larciani and the Fucecchio Altar-Piece

    By Louis Alexander Waldman

    Ever since his oeuvre was constructed over thirty-five years ago by Federico Zeri, the painter known as the 'Master of the Kress Landscapes' has been recognised as one of the most idiosyncratic and intriguing painters of the Florentine maniera - and one of its most perplexing enigmas.' Taking his Notname from three landscape spalliere now in the National Gallery in Washington (Fig.20), the so-called 'Kress Master' is the author of some twenty pictures, which reveal a vigorously imaginative and wholly individual style distinguished by a nervously calligraphic and occasionally awkward draughtsmanship, offset by a vibrant palette and richly sensuous impasto. As his pseudonym suggests, the 'Kress Master' often filled the backgrounds of his pictures with intensely beautiful landscapes, typically combining dramatic Dureresque ter- rains, forlorn crags or fantastic cities and lanky, angular figures sketched with a confident, lightning-swift brush. Scholars, taking their lead from stylistic influences detected in his work, have conjecturally identified this anonymous Mannerist with various of the nomi senza quadrimentioned by Vasari.2 But thanks to three recently discovered contracts for the artist's most important work - his dated altar-piece of 1523 in the Museo Civico of Fucecchio (Fig. 19) - the master can at last be securely identified and given the foundations of a biography." He is revealed as a Florentine painter by the name of Giovanni di Lorenzo Larciani (1484-1527), who does not even receive a passing mention from Vasari. Taking the contracts as a starting point, it has also been possible to clarify the problematic iconography of the Fucecchio altar- piece and to reconstruct the circumstances of the commission. In addition, questions can now be posed about the painter's artistic formation and his place in early Cinquecento Florentine art.

     

     

     

     

  • A Painting by Giovanni Larciani in Rouen

    By David Franklin

    Now that Louis Waldman has shown, in his article published on pp.456-69 above, that the so-called 'Master of the Kress landscapes' is the Florentine painter Giovanni di Lorenzo Larciani, it should be possible to define more closely the achievement of this talented but neglected artist within the context of his time, and to assemble something approaching a coherent catalogue of his work.

     

  • Sts Processus and Martinianus in the Sancta Sanctorum

    By Barbara Deimling

    The recent restoration of the thirteenth-century frescoes and mosaics in the Chapel of St Lawrence in the Lateran, known as the Sancta Sanctorum, is surely one of the greatest art-historical reclamations in recent years.' The chapel was built and decorated in the reign of Pope Nicholas III between 1277 and 1279. Its fresco-cycle shows Nicholas offering the chapel to the enthroned Christ, surrounded by scenes from the lives of Sts Peter and Paul, Nicholas of Myra, Agnes, Stephen and Lawrence. Apart from Nicholas of Myra, the pope's patron saint, all the other saints are early- Christian martyrs who suffered in Rome. This selection, together with the collection of relics of martyrs preserved in the altar of the chapel and the series of saints painted in arches underneath each scene,2 was consistent with Nicholas III's promotion of Rome as the centre of the Christian church established by the apostles Peter and Paul.3 The idea of conjuring up the origins of the church in Rome was enhanced by the presence in the Sancta Sanctorum of the icon of the Saviour, the Acheropita, which was considered to be a 'national Palladium' symbolising the independence of Rome.4 The fresco of the Crucifixion of St Peter on the south wall of the chapel (Fig.37) reveals the pope's political agenda most clearly, incorporating as it does a backdrop view of Rome, apparently the first to beintegrated into this scene.5 It is possible to identify the Capitoline at the far left, followed by the Meta Romuli, the Castel S. Angelo, and probably the Palace of Nero.6

     

  • New Documents for Signorelli's 'Annunciation' at Volterra

    By Tom Henry

    Signorelli's Annunciation in the Pinacoteca Civica at Volterra (Fig.41) has long been recognised as one of the artist's great works. It is signed and dated in an inscription at the bottom of the first pier of the loggia - LVCAS CORTONEN PINXIT MXDI - and it has been correctly assumed that it was painted for the confraternity of the Virgin Mary, whose oratory is attached to the Cathedral in Volter- ra.' It was not mentioned by Vincenzo Borghini in his notebooks of 1558 or by Vasari in either edition of the Vite, but was first described in this oratory in a manuscript guide to Volterra of 1740/41 (see Appendix 3, below). Confirmation of the provenance is found in a group of unpublished documents recording payments to Signorelli, which also shed new light on the date of the commission and how it was financed (see Appendix 1 and 2).

     

  • Pamela Askew (1925-97)

    By Ruth Rubinstein
  • Bernice Davidson (1927-98)

    By Edgar Munhall